The Hondamatic is a great transmission but with the engine upgrades of the Rancher 420 and the increased torque, Honda felt for reliability reasons they should upgrade the Rancher Automatic. They still offer the manual and the electric shift. I have a Rancher 420 AT with the new 5 speed auto, 800 miles and no problems. Shifts very well and the added power of the 09 engine is a nice bonus. I have a good friend who owns a Rubicon and a 07 Rancher, says he wants a new Rancher, loves the added power. There have been a lot of issues with the electric shift, hopefully Honda will get that resolved.