My manager put new tyres on his JD Gator and went for Sun-F brand because they were cheap. So far they have held up really well. The terrain varies here at work from mud to Tarmac (asphalt). The majority of the terrain here has flint in the ground, a LOT of flint, so far you can only see slight cuts to the tread lugs and not to the tyre carcass.
We don’t abuse the Gator so the tyres are never spun unless in mud during the winter, I should imagine that makes a big difference to tyre care.
So my opinion differs to others, there a good all round tyre IF you take care of them. I can’t comment for abusing them as we don’t do that.
A good alternative which wouldn’t break the bank would be a bear claw, we all know there a good all round tyre and a good brand too, tried and tested.