[Treed636]

Cant decide between the two. I wanna hear yalls opinions about it.

 

[Eric the red]

Wide tires float.
If you ride in deep water with a hard bottom, floating is bad as it makes it easy to tip over.
If you ride in swampy grassy stuff with no bottom floating is good.
I have no idea what you ride your atv in so cant recommend one or the other.